Back to Main Menu
Printable PDF files
 WEBTECH Teacher Forms
 WEBTECH Teacher Daily Follow Up Form (T.4)
 WEBTECH Student Forms

EVALUATION PLAN and FORMS

 

Developed for the WebTech Project
By Michal Lomask, Director
ETGaR Company for Evaluation Studies



Teacher Name_____________________ 


To the field test teacher:

The WebTech is an experimental program designed to develop on-line materials for high school technology learning. The program is funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF) and it includes development, application and evaluation components.

The evaluation component of the WebTech program is based on three main guiding questions:

1. What do students learn through their experiences with the WebTech units?
2. What do teachers learn through their experiences with the WebTech units?
3. How do teachers' pedagogy and students' learning in the WebTech units reflect national math, science and technology education standards?

To answer these questions you will be asked to do the following:

1. Participate in training workshop activities
2. Complete questionnaire forms after the workshop (forms T1, T2 and T3)
3. Provide all students with a parent/guardian consent form to be signed
4. Administer pre-tests to student in the WebTech class (forms S1 and S2) and mail them to project evaluator
5. Complete daily "check-up" (form T4)
6. Teach the assigned module and collect sample work produced by students (form T5)
7. Provide a sample of pictures of students' models/final products
8. Administer the post-test and evaluation form to student in the WebTech class (forms S3, S4,S5)
9. Complete the unit evaluation (form T6)
10. Send all materials to project evaluator


Data collected by you and by the project leaders will be analyzed to answer the above evaluation questions.
The final report will be sent to you as soon as it will be available.


Thank you very much for your participation and contribution to the success of this project.

 

 

Teacher Name_____________________


Form T1: General Information


1) How many years have you been teaching, what and where? ( Please start with your most recent position)



 

2) What is your major teaching discipline/s?



 

3) In what class/grade level do you plan to teach the WebTech unit?



 

4) How many computers do you have in your classroom and/or lab room?



 

5) Do students in your class have easy access to computers during the school day? At home?



 

6) What are the topics students in your class will learn before and after this unit?
Before:


After:


7) Describe the general academic level of students in your class



Teacher Name_____________________        


Form T2: Familiarity with Educational Standards:

Use this scale to answer each one of the following questions: 4 = Very
3 = Fairly
2 = Somewhat
1 = Not at all

 
4
3
2
1
 Educational Standards        
 How familiar are you with the National Standards for  Technological Literacy (NSTL)?        
 How familiar are you with the National Science Education  Standards (NSES)?        
 How familiar are you with the NYS Learning Standards for  mathematics, science and technology?        
 How familiar are you with the National Council of Teachers of  Mathematics (NCTM) Standards?        
 Instructional practices        
 How familiar are you with the use of science laboratory activities  with students?        
 How familiar are you with the use of projects or extended  investigations?
       
 How familiar are you with the use of the technology design cycle?

       
 How familiar are you with the use of student journals/portfolios?

       
 How familiar are you with strategies to develop students' ability to  communicate ideas?        
 How familiar are you with the use of on-line resources for  instruction?

       
 How familiar are you with traditional teaching methods?

       
 Preparation        
 How well prepared do you feel you are to teach standard-based  technology?        
 How well prepared do you feel you are to teach standard-based  science?
       
 How well prepared do you feel you are to teach standard-based  mathematics?        
 How well prepared do you feel you are to teach the WebTech  module?
       


 




Teacher Name_____________________



T3: Post-workshop Feedback

 

8) What are the main insights you gained about the use of the engineering design cycle in the WebTech module?



 

 

 


9) What are the main insights that you gained about the role of science in the WebTech module?



 

 

 

 

10) What are the main insights that you gained about the role of mathematics in the WebTech units?



 

 

 


11) What are the main insights that you gained about the use of the Internet in the WebTech units?



 

 

 


12) How can the workshop be improved for future training?



 

Teacher Name_____________________


T5: Examples of Student Work

 

At the end of the unit please collect the design folios or project notebook completed by three students who represent different levels of achievement (i.e., low, medium and high level). If students want to keep their work, please make copies of their folios. Also collect sample work to illustrate student performances during the unit. The samples can be collected from different students and it may include any of the following:

· Lab reports
· Homework
· Drawings
· Pictures of models
· PowerPoint presentations
· Other material


 



 

Teacher Name_____________________


Form T6: Tell us what you think


Please reflect about your experience with the WebTech unit and briefly answer the following questions:

1. What was your most difficult task during this experience?
_______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________

2. What support did you receive from Project leaders during the implementation of the unit?
_______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________

3. What support did you receive from your school/district?
_______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________

4. What were, if any, the barriers to successful implementation of the unit?
_______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________

5. How can the module be improved?
_______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________

6. Will you be interested in teaching other WebTech units? If so, what type of support would you need?
_______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________ _______________________________________________________________________________




Teacher Name_____________________


Parent/Guardian Consent Form


Dear Parent or Guardian:


The WebTech Project was developed at the State Universities of New York at Buffalo and Stony Brook and funded by the National Science Foundation. The Project is presently conducting a fieldtest of new curriculum modules to improve their value to students and teachers. These modules were designed to enhance students' technology, math and science knowledge and skills through hands-on and web-based learning activities. The new curriculum was tested by expert teachers and their classes in a pilot study, and the results were used to revise the project materials and ready them for field testing. This fieldtest is designed to further evaluate the quality of the curriculum materials and their impact on student learning.

We are writing to notify you that your child will participate in the study of this new curriculum. He or she will complete all class assignments and be tested for mastery of the curriculum content, as is normally done with all regular coursework.

Your child will be also asked to complete a questionnaire about his/her reaction to the new materials. Work done by your child during the unit might be selected to be evaluated by project staff. Materials gathered during the field study are used for the evaluation of the project and not for grading students. Therefore, all information provided by your child will be confidential.

Should you have any questions regarding this study, you may contact Dr. David Shaw dshaw @buffalo.edu or at 716-645-3112 Ext. 1218



>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>


I, (print name) _____________________________________, the parent or legal guardian of the student (print name) ________________________________ give my consent to the WebTech Project to gather materials and work produced by my child in the project unit. I understand that these materials will be used for evaluation research only.


Parent signature: _____________________________________     Date: ____________________



* Please sign this form and send it back to school with the student

 

 


Teacher Name_____________________


Scoring Rubric for Student Learning Outcomes

 

Score Point
Criteria for Scoring
Exemplary
(4)

Student work shows:

· Comprehensive knowledge of the topic
· In-depth understanding of topic-related concepts and ideas
· Use of data and examples to illustrate main arguments or point of view
· Logical and coherent flow of ideas and arguments

Overall, the work is exemplary, detailed and clear.

Proficient
(3)

Student work shows:

· Knowledge of the topic
· Good understanding of topic-related concepts and ideas
· Some use of data and examples to illustrate main arguments or point of view
· Good development of ideas and arguments

Overall, the work is good, has some detail, and is clear.

Developing competency
(2)

Student work shows:

· Some knowledge of the topic, but may include content inaccuracies
· Some understanding of topic-related concepts, but there are apparent gaps in understanding the relations among main ideas
· Some use of supporting facts and examples
· An apparent effort, although not completely successful, to put together ideas and arguments

Overall, the work is satisfactory, but the answer may be vague or not well developed and may include content inaccuracies.

Novice
(1)

Student work shows:

· Little knowledge of the topic
· Limited understanding of main ideas
· Unsupported arguments
· Misconceptions, inaccurate or irrelevant information

Overall, the work is poor and lacks clarity.

Unscorable
(0)

The student either:

· left the answer blank
· wrote about a different topic